Jump to Recipe (You're Welcome)

Casey and Avery's Banana Bread

Just bake the loaf.

This is my wife Casey's banana bread. My 21-year-old daughter Avery has been making it her whole life and has loudly refined it into the version below — Avery does not hold opinions quietly, and you would hear about each of these changes from her personally if she were here — more bananas, one bowl, sharper bake window. I do not bake it. I eat it standing over the kitchen counter like a raccoon. The two of them are the entire kitchen on this one; I am the courier.

It's banana bread. You wanted banana bread. Congratulations on your towering culinary ambitions. The recipe is short. There are seven ingredients and seven steps. Don't fuck up the mixing and don't fuck up the bake time and you will have banana bread. If you can mash a banana, you can do this. If you can't mash a banana, what the hell are you even doing here.

Prep: 10 min Cook: 50-60 min Makes: 1 loaf If You Can Mash a Banana
A golden-brown loaf of banana bread on a white plate, with a clean crack down the center of the top crust.
Casey and Avery's loaf, baked by Avery and photographed by Casey. That crack down the middle is what you want. I just ate three slices and called it research.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Preheat the oven to 350°F (175°C). Lightly grease a 9x5-inch loaf pan. Parchment sling optional but it makes lift-out a non-event — future you will thank past you.
  2. In a single large bowl — yes, one, that's not a typo — beat the brown sugar and softened butter with an electric mixer until smooth. If the butter wasn't actually softened, nothing will be smooth and you'll be standing there mashing cold yellow lumps wondering where it all went wrong. Soften the butter.
  3. Stir in the beaten eggs and the mashed bananas until well blended. The bowl looks like a wet, slightly weird mess. It's supposed to. Keep going.
  4. Add the flour, baking soda, and salt to the same bowl. Stir until just combined. This is the only step that can ruin the whole loaf. Overmix and you get a dense, gummy, tough banana brick — the kind you cannot give away, because the people you give it to will quietly throw it in the trash and stop trusting you. Glossy smooth batter means you went too far. Streaks of dry flour mean you didn't go far enough. Lumpy and mostly incorporated is what you want. Stop early. Trust the bake.
  5. Pour the batter into the prepared loaf pan.
  6. Bake 50 to 60 minutes. Start checking at 45. Toothpick in the center should come out with a few moist crumbs. If it's bone dry, you went too long, and your banana bread is already sawdust — there's no fixing this on the back end, so pull it the second it tests done. Wet batter on the toothpick means another few minutes. Ovens are liars. Watch yours.
  7. Cool in the pan for 10 minutes, then turn out onto a wire rack and cool completely before slicing. I know it smells incredible. I know you want a slice. Cut into it warm and you get gummy bread, you'll blame the recipe, the recipe will be fine, and you'll be wrong. Walk away from the loaf.

Read This Before You Mix

Three or four bananas. Five is over the limit. Casey ran it at three bananas for years. Avery defaults to four. Either is right; five is wrong. Some people will tell you to load this thing up with as much banana as you can fit — "more banana is more flavor!" — and those people are wrong. Past four bananas it stops being banana bread and starts being a wet pudding loaf that never sets in the middle. Three to four medium overripe bananas, mashed, is about 1 to 1 1/2 cups. That's the window. Stay in it.

Use overripe bananas. The blacker the better. Black and heavily speckled. Soft enough that a fork goes through them like nothing. Yellow bananas haven't developed their sugars yet and the bread will taste like a wet napkin pretending to be banana. If your bananas aren't ripe enough, leave them on the counter another day — or, if you don't have a day, throw them whole on a sheet tray skin-on at 300°F for about 30 minutes. They come out gross and brown and perfect. Do not peel them first unless you want to clean an oven.

One bowl. That is the whole pitch. Some banana bread recipes will tell you to mix dry in one bowl and wet in another and then fold them together. Why? No reason. It's two bowls instead of one for an identical outcome. Avery dropped that step years ago. Bread's the same. Save yourself the dish.

The two rules. Break either one and the loaf is ruined. Banana bread is forgiving about almost everything — bananas a little under, a little over, sugar measured by feel, butter slightly less than soft. None of that ruins the loaf. Two things do. Don't overmix. Don't overbake. The recipe lives or dies on these.

Don't overmix. Stir until just combined and then stop. Smooth, glossy, fully-blended batter is overmixed, and overmixed banana bread comes out dense, gummy, and tough — a banana brick you cannot give away. The people you give it to will quietly throw it in the trash and stop trusting you. Stop at lumpy. Trust the oven to finish the job.

Don't overbake. Banana bread goes from "perfect" to "dry crumbly disappointment" in about 4 minutes. Start checking at 45 minutes. Pull it the second the toothpick comes out with a few moist crumbs clinging to it. If the toothpick is bone dry, the bread is already overbaked — you're not going to rescue it by wrapping it in plastic or pretending it's "rustic." Set a timer. Check it. Be there.

Cool completely before slicing. The 10 minutes in the pan plus the time on the rack isn't a polite suggestion — the bread is still finishing in there. Slice it warm and it tears and goes gummy and you'll think the recipe shorted you. It didn't. You shorted it. Make a cup of coffee. Resist the loaf.

Stuff You'll Need

A 9x5-inch loaf pan. An electric mixer (handheld is fine; nobody's hauling out a stand mixer for one loaf). A mixing bowl. One. A fork to mash the bananas — a potato masher works too, your clean hands work, just get it done. A wire rack. A toothpick. That's it. If you don't own any of this, you don't own a kitchen, you own a room with a fridge in it.