Jump to Recipe (You're Welcome)

French Toast

(The Classic Sibling of the Crostini. Same Custard, Different Sunday Morning.)

French toast. Bread, eggs, cream, butter, pan, heat. That's the whole recipe. If you have made French toast at IHOP's hands before and it came out soggy in the middle and rubbery on the outside, that's not French toast's fault — you soaked the bread like you were trying to drown it. Two seconds per side. Not thirty. Not "until it feels heavy." Two. Seconds. This recipe is the classic breakfast-plate version of the French Toast Crostini we already have on the site — same technique, same custard, same warning about the bread; different final format. Both are correct. Pick your morning.

Prep: 5 min Cook: 15 min Serves: 4 Easy (Two Seconds, Not Thirty)
Two slices of golden French toast on a white plate topped with deep purple-red mixed berry compote and a dusting of powdered sugar
Compote on top is our Mixed Berry Compote; the recipe is one page over. Dust of powdered sugar because we felt fancy.

Ingredients

The Bread

The Custard

The Pan

Toppings (Pick Some, All Valid)

Instructions

  1. Cut the bread. Diagonally, about 1 inch thick. Diagonal because more surface area and because it looks nicer on the plate. Thick enough to hold up to the custard bath without falling apart, not so thick that the middle stays raw and eggy.
  2. Whisk the custard. In a wide shallow bowl (wide enough to lay a slice of bread in flat), whisk 4 eggs, 1/2 cup heavy cream, 1 tsp vanilla, 1 tsp cinnamon, and a pinch of salt until smooth — no visible egg-white streaks, cinnamon distributed. Cinnamon likes to float on top; whisk it hard until it stops trying.
  3. Heat the pan. Medium heat. Add enough butter to coat the bottom of the pan in a thin, even film when it melts. Not a puddle. Not a scrape. A film. The pan is ready when the butter is bubbling but not browning.
  4. Dip. Two seconds. Not more. Lay the bread in the custard, count to two, flip, count to two, lift and let the excess drip off. Every side coated. Do NOT soak. Oversoaked bread turns into a wet sponge that will not crisp, will fall apart in the pan, and will deliver a raw-eggy gummy center. Get the bread coated, not colonized.
  5. Cook. Lay each coated slice into the buttered pan. Cook each side 2-3 minutes until golden brown. Do not crowd the pan — leave breathing room between slices. Steamed French toast is sad French toast. Between batches, add more butter as needed.
  6. Serve immediately, hot. Top with compote, syrup, brown sugar, or whatever else you want. See the callout below for what pairs, what doesn't, and what to avoid.

Don't Soak the Bread. Two Seconds.

This is the same technique cliff the French Toast Crostini page warns about, and it's still the entire game on this recipe. Two seconds per side in the custard, out. Oversoaked bread is a wet dishrag that will refuse to crisp and will hand you a gummy center that no amount of butter or heat can fix. If the bread feels heavy and floppy in your hand before it hits the pan, you left it in too long — toss it and dip the next one faster. See the crostini recipe for the extended lecture; the short version is: two. seconds.

Homemade Italian Bread, or Store-Bought If You're a Lazy Ass.

Homemade Italian bread is the ideal — dense enough to hold up, tender enough to soak the custard, and the small commitment of baking a loaf pays back on breakfast for a week. If you're not baking, grocery-store Italian bread is fine — you're a lazy ass, but you're a lazy ass with breakfast on the table. What is NOT fine: sliced sandwich bread (Wonder Bread turns to mush in the custard and to sadness on the plate), stale bread that has gone actually rock-hard (it won't rehydrate through the custard fast enough at two seconds), or a baguette (too thin, all crust, the custard has nowhere to go). A good sturdy Italian loaf is the correct call.

The Butter Amount.

Enough to coat the bottom of the pan in an even film when it melts. Not a puddle — that will pool around the toast and fry the edges greasy while the middle still steams. Not a scrape — that will burn to brown flecks before the toast is even in and glue the toast to the pan when the sugar in the custard hits the hot metal. Thin film, refreshed between batches. That's it. And it's butter, not margarine — the fake tub stuff is a chemistry experiment, not a fat.

Toppings — Compote Is the Site Pick.

Our Mixed Berry Compote is what's in the hero photo above, and it's the pairing this recipe was built for. Keep a jar in the fridge and every breakfast for the next two weeks gets fancier for free. Other legitimate toppings: real maple syrup (the amber liquid that came out of a tree, not the corn-syrup impostor with "maple flavoring"), a pat of butter melting on top while it's still hot, brown sugar dusted on while the toast is warm, powdered sugar for the photo. Combinations are fine — syrup and berries, butter and brown sugar, all fair game. Whipped cream if you're going the dessert-for-breakfast route. What is not on the guest list: pancake syrup pretending to be maple, and canned pie filling. Do not put canned pie filling on French toast. We are not at a Denny's.

Related — French Toast Crostini.

If you like this and want a plank-format finger-food version with a maple-cream-cheese layer, see French Toast Crostini on this site. Same underlying technique — bread + eggy custard + pan — different final format and a different topping strategy. Both live here. Pick your morning.

Stuff You'll Need

A large skillet or griddle. A wide shallow bowl for the custard — wide enough that a slice of bread lays flat. A whisk. A cutting board and a serrated knife for the bread. A spatula. A plate to land on. That's it. Nothing here requires a special tool. If a recipe blogger tries to sell you a "French toast dip tray," ignore them.